Wildcard Redirect from non-hosted URL to hosted url
I am trying to redirect site1.com/EVERY-VALUE to site2.com/. Site1 is a non-hosted url but when site1.com/every-value1, site1.com/everyvalue2, etc., is clicked, our current redirect produces a 404 on site2.com.
I want site1.com/EVERY-VALUE to land on site2.com/ without creating a 404.
I added an A record forwarding *., ad Godaddy suggested, but this did not work for me.
Does anyone have any suggestions? If so, please share and thank you very much.