Can't finish setup for Outlook on new Android

[Brocephus]

I previously had Outlook set up on an LG G5.  No problems.  I recently upgraded to a Pixel 2XL and I am having trouble connecting to my account.

I follow the directions here for adding an account and I have also just launched Outlook and clicked "GET STARTED".  I then 1) receive a request for an email address.  2) A GoDaddy login page is displayed asking for a password.  I enter the password (I am sure the password is correct because I purposefully also entered the incorrect password to test the error message).  3) I get a spinner that just spins indefinitely.

I have tried this both on WiFi and using cellular data.