Hi @SpicersMill. Thanks for being part of GoDaddy Community! There are two modifiers you can add to a GoCentral Store product, options, and add-ons. I think you might be able to do what you want by using add-ons. You are limited to adding 3 options, but I was able to add up to 4 add-ons. To do this, I created a product called "spice 4-pack". Then, I added 4 separate add-ons that were required for the customer to choose. I left the price blank so that the overall price was specific to all 4 and not varied by the type of spice. That may work for you. However, it may get tedious if you sell a large variety of spices as each add-on you set up has to be added manually. See images below.